The Great Debate Essay Example for Free

The Great Debate EssaySex and gender, nature and nurture these ar some foot cargo deck that encounter been the heat of debate among the Social Science field for some time. Sex and gender have been used as interchanging terms for legion(predicate) years. You may ask, is there a difference? Yes, there is. Sex refers to the biological differences, chromosomes, hormonal profiles, internal and external come alive organs (Nobelius, NPG). sex activity refers to char beteristics that a partnership or culture delineates as masculine or feminine (Nobelius, NPG). The debate over sex/gender and nature versus nurture has been intriguing to many in the Social Science realm. Social Science has long been concerned with the extent to which certain aspects of behavior atomic number 18 a product of contractable (nature) or experienceed characteristics (nurture). Nature deals with the aspects of our being that atomic number 18 innate, art object nurture regards how environ custodytal a spects affect us. There is little doubt that genes (nature) determine such things as eye, tomentum cerebri or skin color.But the nature versus nurture debate bewitchks to understand how a person develops factors such as personality, intelligence and behavioral traits. There atomic number 18 many questions that arise with this debate. We know that both nature and nurture play parts in defining us as people, only if exactly how untold? If everything in our personality can be changed by our environment and how we learn, because does our birth sex matter? Does being male give the right to be the head of the house? And does being the m different al focuss taut you have to raise the children? In my paper, I am going to discuss the chronicle if this great debate of nature versus nurture, patrilineal and matrilineal societies as well as other cultures and how they function, followed by a brief summary and my conclusion.Going back into the history books, we know many people studied this topic (and similar behaviorism topics), people such as John B. Watson, Margargont Mead, Marshall Sahlins and B. F. Skinner. We can see the earlier recorded debate over this topic, using the terms nature and nurture started in France during the 13th century (Tree.com, NPG) in a manuscript titled Silence. though the exact terminology was nature and noreture (for nurture) these terms were used to discuss characteristics that worked to shape ones personality (Tree.com, NPG). 600 years later was the next instance by a man named Francis Galton in 1874 (Tree.com, NPG). In Galtons work English Men of Science Their Nature and Nurture, published in 1874, Galton states Nature and nurture are a accessible jingle of words, for it separates under two distinct heads the innumerable elements of which personality is composed. Nature is all that a man brings with himself into the world nurture is every influence that affects him after his birth (Tree.com, NPG).The meaning has stayed the same fo r the centuries that have passed, so lets take a look at different types of societies, patriarchal (patrilineal) and matricentric (matrilineal) and see if there are differences. The term patriarchal defines a social system in which the male acts as the primary authority figure, central to the social organization, and where fathers hold authority over women, children and property (Wikipedia 3, NPG). Patrilineal refers to relating to, establish on, or tracing ancestral descent though the paternal line (Dictionary, NPG), so, matriarchy and matrilineal mean the same, except for the women.We will look at Patriarchal/patrilineal societies first, starting with the United States, being both of these. Patriarchy in the United States is based upon the opinion of white male superiority. All others, those who are white and females, non-white and male, and non white and female, for example, are generally excluded from positions of privilege and power (Reviere, pg. 1). In my opinion, the United States is a land that speaks of equivalence between race, gender and ethnic backgrounds, but does not act as such women are often paid less than men for the same jobs, women are often objectified more than their male counterparts and women are often treated as inferior citizens.The males are taught early on that they are stronger, more superior to girls, they are molded and shaped by the toys they play with, how we (parents) talk to them, TV and movies. They are to be a mans man and to act tough, macho and not cry. They are to be the head of the house, run the roost and be the breadwinner for the family. In the United States, the majority of the decisions are do by males, they run the political and phantasmal aspects of the country as well as most households.Other counties that have patriarchal societies include (but are not limited to) Saudi Arabia, Italy, Uganda and Germany. In Saudi Arabia their religion, Islam, governs the way day-to-day life is ran. In contemporary Muslim patriarchal societies, such control over women is considered necessary in part because women are regarded as the potential source of fitna, that is, moral or social disorder (Mernissi, 1987). Also, women of all ages are required to have a male guardian all women, no matter of age, are required to have a male guardian (Wikipedia 4, NPG).This guardian is the decision maker over things like education, marriage, elective surgeries, travel, work, etc. (Wikipedia 4, NPG). It is usually her husband, brother, or someone close within the family (Wikipedia 4, NPG). Also, women cannot vote or be elected to high political positions law in addition prohibits them from driving (Wikipedia 4, NPG). The World Economic fabrication 2009 Global Gender Gap field ranked Saudi Arabia 130th out of 134 countries for gender parity. It was the only country to score a zero in the category of political empowerment (Wikipedia 4, NPG).In Italy, womens sufferage came about and women were liberated somewhat. Wo men were allowed to vote in 1945 and were elected to Parliament in 1946 and in like manner took part in the drafting of the Italian Constitution that same year (123, NPG). For centuries, women were banned from the public arena, and Italy existed as a patriarchal companionship. Today, women have more rights, especially in the workplace, but Italian women deal with increased responsibilities in other areas while being expected to sustain their responsibilities at home without help from their spouses (123, NPG).They are deemed the ultimate homemakers (Andrews, NPG). removed more than in America or the UK, Italian mothers in the twenty-first century tend to be home-makers while their husbands go out to work (Andrews, NPG). time they are allowed to work and charge be in the political jobs, they are also expected to run the household entirely, Italian women are faced with the projection of working full time and also coming home to the full-time job of being a homemaker (Wicket, NPG) . While Italian women are become more modern, working, voting, and even being elected to high political positions, the wit among men is lock that of the old times (123, NPG). Actions wont change until the mindset of certain equality sets in.In Uganda, tradition dies hard. Uganda has a very patriarchal culture, so much so that, despite government, the people deny women rights and gender based violence is very high. The government is making tough decisions and laws to help aid women in the fend for for equality (Irinnews, NPG). President Yoweri Museveni has been trying to make huge strides in equality over the last 25 years, but with little success. President Museveni verbalize in 2002, womens rights for the first time have been enshrined in the Ugandan constitution.Ugandas womens movement has grown dramatically into a vibrant political force throughout the country. Uganda also is the first African country to have appointed a cleaning woman as vice president. The affirmative action policy has, for example, ensured that at least a third of legislative and civic positions were reserved for women. The Ugandan government also introduced a Universal Primary Education (UPE) policy to provide vindicate education to four children per family, two of whom must be girls. (Irinnews, NPG).Presently, the Ugandan government has offered assist in furthering womens rights, economic and infrastructure issues continue to prevent women from achieving gender equality (Irinnews, NPG). But even with a tough government, customary laws and traditions are still hard to fight. Traditions in Uganda die hard and ownership of land upon death of the husband, is one of those. Uganda is still doublely a patrilineal society. Customary practices that place women in an inferior position continue to operate in many communities in spite of the statutory laws that condemn such practices. Under customary law, women do not inherit property on widowhood. When a man dies, the clan immediately appoints an heir. The heir is usually the first son in the family. He inherits the property of the departed and he is supposed to take care of everybody in the home (Asiimwe, pg. 8).Another issue in Uganda would be gendered violence. Although President Museveni has condemned violence against women, it still takes place, he stated gender-based violence and other discriminatory practices in our society have also hampered women from using their skills in development activities and prevented them from claiming their social-economic rights, for example, property rights and inheritance (Ssempogo, NPG).While women play a central role in society, and few have been empowered, he noted most are still trapped in the low-income category (Ssempogo, NPG). In 2007, it was describe that 70 percent of women, since the age of 15 years, had experienced some form of violence (physical or sexual) inflicted by their spouse or intimate partner and 16 percent have experienced it during pregnancy (UDHS, pg. 15). Ugandas President isnt giving up hope or his fight. He still persists with his fight for equality, fight to end violence against women and pushes for women to be landowners, even without a males involvement.Looking at matriarchic and matrilineal societies, we will first discuss the Iroquois tribe, then the Minangkabau people of West Sumatra, the Mosou of China and finally the Asante of the Akan in Ghana. First looking at the Iroquois, while they are now a chapter out of our history books, they were sincerely a matriarchal and matrilineal society. In the Iroquois community, women were the keepers of culture they enjoyed equality and respect (Portland State University, NPG). They were responsible for defining the political, social, spiritual and economic norms of the tribe (Portland State University, NPG).Iroquois society was matrilineal, meaning descent was traced through the mother rather than through the father (Portland State University, NPG). They also preformed many t asks and activities that were commonly reserved for men, such as, gambling, Medicine Societies, they also participated in politics, were landowners and tended to the crops (Portland State University, NPG). Also, when a couple marries, the man traditionally went to live with the wifes family (Portland State University, NPG). Although the leaders were men, it was the Clan Mothers who nominated and elected them, and could remove them from their position the women made sure the male leadership fulfilled their responsibilities (Portland State University, NPG).The Minangkabau are the largest and most stable matrilineal society in the world today, numbering some 4 million people in West Sumatra (Sanday, NPG). They are a proud people well known in Indonesia for their literary flair, democratic leanings, business acumen, and matriarchal ways (Sanday, NPG). With the Minangkabau people, tribal law requires all clan property to be held and bequeathed from mother to daughter, the Minangkabau fir mly believe the mother is the most important person in society.Upon marriage, every woman acquires her own sleeping quarters. The husband may sleep with her, but must leave early in the morning to have breakfast at his mothers home. At age 10, boys leave their mothers home to stay in mens quarters and learn practical skills. Men are always clan chief, but women select the chief and can remove him from office should they feel he failed to fulfill his duties (Garrison, NPG) Their matriarchal customs are being threated by the industrialization of Indonesia (Sanday, NPG). Westernized culture is influencing parts of Indonesia with malls, bookstores and public transportation (Sanday, NPG). But the Minangkabau people are holding tight to the reigns of their way of life, not giving up so easily to outside influences.The Mosuo are perhaps the most famous matrilineal society. The Mosuo live with extended family in large households at the head of each is a matriarch. Lineage is traced through the female side and property is passed and inherited along the matriline (Garrison, NPG). Women are business minded while the men run the political side children are raised in the mothers household, and also take her name (Garrison, NPG). In this society, there is nigh no violence in fact, it is shameful to fight (Spiegel, NPG). Men are expected to finish the tasks give (by women), when he doesnt, he is expected to admit it he is not scolded or punished, but yet, treated as a boy who was not up to the task (Spiegel, NPG).Men are raised to be competent, men are good for aiding in decision making and physical labor and the Mayor is a male, but little attention is paid to him and he doesnt have authority (figurehead) (Spiegel, NPG). Women decide with whom they want to spend the night, it can change daily (Spiegel, NPG). When a man enters a womans house (hut), he hangs his hat on a hook, outside the front door for others to see this woman has a male visitor (Spiegel, NPG). In the event a woman recalls in love, she will only accept this man and this man will only come to this woman (Spiegel, NPG). The women solely care for the children, with the father vie little to no role (Spiegel, NPG). In the Mosuo society, women are the sole caretakers, money managers, leaders, laborers, and decision makers (Spiegel, NPG). They have virtually no use for the man except to fall in love with and for child-making, other than that, the men are useless until given a task by a woman (Spiegel, NPG).Lastly, the Asante of the Akan. The Akan are the majority in Ghana and still adhere to the matrilineal social structure despite pressures from the local government to change (Garrison, NPG). The Akan social organization is fundamentally built slightly the matriclan. Within this matrilineal clan, identity, inheritance, wealth and politics are all determined. All matriclan founders are female, but men traditionally hold leadership positions. Succession to transmissible appointments is st ill determined by the males relationships to the women in his matriclan. Often, the man is expected to not only support his own family, but those of his female relatives (Garrison, NPG).In the Asante tribe (part of the Akan), traditionally, both men and women serve as political leaders. The highest-level female leader is believed to be the mother of the entire society and it is she who chooses the male leadership (Brydon, 229). Asantes ancestry is traced to a mother figure and through the line (Brydon, 229). Their stories and folklores also originate from a motherly figure (Brydon, 229). Although a womans brothers and sons have superior claim to property, women control the resources (Brydon, 229). Females are also responsible for settling domestic affairs (Brydon, 229). Asantes women are viewed both internally (by the clans) and outwardly (by other cultures) and a strong and empowered female centered society (Brydon, 229)So the Great Debate asks, all of what we learn, our behavior, our intelligence, our way we are, is it internally inclined or socially constructed? In my Section A paper, I referenced a study done by Margaret Mead in New Guinea in the 1930s. In this study, she used ethnography to study three tribes, their behavior, their children and the results were immediately noticeable. The tribes were the Arapesh, the Mundugumor and the Tchumbuli (Lindsey, pg. 21-22). Tribal children regurgitated the behaviors learned by their parents and other tribe members. The Arapesh were noted in the text as compassionate and compliant between both genders (Lindsey, pg. 21). Both genders achieved great amounts of pleasure in tasks such as gardening, hunting and parenting (Lindsey, pg. 21). The Arapesh shared these tasks equally and willingly (Lindsey, pg. 21).Mead concluded that even though some societies have labeled tasks as paternal/maternal, their tasks (Arapesh) could not be separated based on gender (Lindsey, pg. 21). The Tchumbuli tribe was comparable to what we are more familiar with in the United States, but in reverse. The Tchumbuli tribe displayed a role reversal in gender roles (Lindsey, pg. 22). This tribe consisted of proficient, and unadorned women and passive, vain, and change men (Lindsey, pg. 22). Women fueled the tribe economically by being skilled in portion outs such as hunting, basket weaving and barter or trade (Lindsey, pg. 22.). Men were less masculine, remained close to the homes, danced and practiced art (Lindsey, pg. 22). Men also fought for the affection and attention of women women usually accepted and tolerated the advances, sometimes even finding their hire for attention amusing (Lindsey, pg. 22).The Mundugumor tribe was drastically different from both tribes. The Mundugumor tribe barely tolerated children (Lindsey, pg. 21). Children were often left to fend for themselves, they were taught to be fierce and hostile, competitive and on the alert of others (Lindsey, pg. 21). Mother nor father showed much affecti on, nurturing or tenderness towards children, even their own and often used harsh, physical punishments (Lindsey, pg. 21). The learned behavior quickly culminated to understanding tribal success being measured by aggression, with violence as acceptable, expected solution to many problems (Lindsey, pg. 21). Due to the hostile, angry nature of the Mundugumor tribe, the children exacted these roles in their adolescent and crowing life with their children and the cycle continued (Lindsey, pg. 21).Mead noted that as with the Arapesh tribe, the Mundugumor tribe did not differentiate between male and female roles. That both male and female roles were correlative and personalities did not differentiate based on gender (Lindsey, pg. 21).This information, coupled with the differences in the patriarchal and matriarchal societies lead me to believe and draw conclusion that nurture is the true winner in the debate. In society, many traits we attribute to being inherited such as how we act like one of our parents, or how we grow up to be a certain way, with certain morals and beliefs but these are not inherited, but merely cultured by the environment (our home life, upbringing). How we act (or the role we play) is largely based on the ideals, morals, beliefs and customs of the society we associate ourselves with.As shown above, many different cultures do things differently, so to say that things are inherited, I would say is wrong. Rather, the term I would use instead is guided- people are guided by their surroundings and families. While they are free to make their own decisions about who they want to be, what they want to believe and such, they are still shaped by what is deemed acceptable or not by the society they live in. It all relates back to cultural relativism, where nurture, not nature, shapes who we are.ReferencesAsiimwe, Florence Owen Crankshaw. The impact of customary laws on inheritance A case study of widows in Urban Uganda. journal of Law and Conflict Reso lution. Vol 3 (1). Jan 2011. Web. 1 August 2012. http//www.academicjournals.org/JLCR/PDF/pdf%202011/Jan/Asiimwe%20and%20Crankshaw.pdfAndrews, Cath. Italian Family Traditions- Mothers, Sons and Marriage in Italy. EZ Articles. 8 April 2010. Web. 1 August 2012. http//ezinearticles.com/?Italian-Family-TraditionsMothers,-Sons-and-Marriage-in-Italyid=4074668Brydon, Lynne. WOMEN CHIEFS AND POWER IN THE VOLTA REGION OF GHANA. daybook OF LEGAL PLURALISM. 1996. Web. 1 August 2012. http//www.jlp.bham.ac.uk/volumes/37-38/brydon-art.pdfDictionary. Patrilineal. TheFreeDictionary.com. 2012. Web. 29 Jul 2012. www.thefreedictionary.com/_/dict.aspx?word=patrilinealGarrison, Laura. 6 Modern Societies Ruled by Women. Mental_Floss. 23 July 2012. Web. 1 August 2012. http//www.mentalfloss.com/blogs/archives/132885Lindsey, Linda. (2005). Gender Roles a Sociological Perspective. (4 ed.). Pearson Education International.Mernissi, Fatima. Beyond the Veil Male-Female Dynamics in Modern Muslim Society. (Revise d Edition). 1987. Bloomington, IN Indiana University PressNobelius, Ann-Maree. What is the difference between sex and gender? Monash University. 23 June 2004. Web. 26 July 2012. WEBLINK NEEDEDN.A. Women in Politics Turkey, Greece, and Italy. 123HelpMe.com. Web. 01 Aug 2012. http//www.123HelpMe.com/view.asp?id=30400N.A. Uganda Focus- Little change for women despite affirmative action. Irinnews.com. 19 Dec 2002. Web. 1 August 2012. http//www.irinnews.org/Report/40192/UGANDA-Focus-Little-change-for-women-despite-affirmative-actionN.a. Nature versus Nurture Genetics and Environment. Tree.com. 2011. Web. 26 July 2012. http//www.tree.com/health/nature-versus-nurture-environment-or-genetics.aspxPortland State University. Iroquois Women. Portland State University. 1 October 2001. Web. 1 August 2012. http//www.iroquoisdemocracy.pdx.edu/html/iroquoiswoman.htmReviere, R. Women in US Prisons screw the Bars of the Patriarchy. University of California, San Diego. N.d. Web. 29 July 2012. www.Dim ension.ucsd.edu/CEIMSA-IN-EXILE/colloques/pdfPatri/ch-9.pdfSanday, Peggy. An excerpt from Women at the Center Life in a Modern Matriarchy. University of Pennsylvania. 2002. Web. 1 August 2012.http//www.sas.upenn.edu/psanday/sanday.htmSpiegel. Men live better where women are in charge. Spiegel International. 28 May 2008. Web. 1 August 2012. http//www.spiegel.de/international/zeitgeist/the-mosuo-matriarchy-men-live-better-where-women-are-in-charge-a-627363.htmlSsempogo, Herbert. Uganda Gender Violence Blocks Women Rights. AllAfrica.com. 5 October 2010. Web. 1 August 2012. http//allafrica.com/stories/201010051114.htmlUDHS- Uganda demographic and Health Survey. Uganda Demographic and Health Survey Key Findings 2006. Uganda Bureau of Statistics. 2006. Web. 1 August 2012. http//www.ubos.org/onlinefiles/uploads/ubos/pdf%20documents/Uganda%20DHS%202006%20Key%20Findings.pdfWicket, Sticky. Italian Culture Produces Patriarchal Society. RiseUP.com. 16 June 2010. Web. 1 August 2012. http//www.us ariseup.com/sticky-wicket-questions/italian-culture-produces-patriarchal-societyWikipedia 1. Nature versus Nurture. Wikepedia.com. 20 July 2012. Web. 26 July 2012. http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nature_versus_nurtureWikipedia 2. John B. Watson. Wikipedia.com. 22 July 2012. Web. 26 July 2012. http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_B._Watson.22Little_Albert.22_experiment_.281920.29Wikipedia 3. Patriarchy. Wikipedia.com. May 2010. Web. 29 July 2012. http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/patriarchyWikipedia 4. Womens rights in Saudi Arabia. Wikipedia.com. 24 July 2012. Web. 29 July 2012.